Q: Think about different metaphors for American society. For many years,
the country was described as a melting pot, which suggests that
differences between citizens are supposed to melt down and blend into
one unified character. Recently, some have criticized this melting pot
metaphor because it emphasizes wiping out differences, not respecting
them. The Reverend Jesse Jackson refers to the United States as both a
rainbow and a family quilt. Both of Jackson's metaphors emphasize
recognizing and appreciating differences. What metaphor would you
propose?
A: I propose that America is more like a family quilt than a rainbow. It just depends on the point of view or standpoint in the position. America is composed of many immigrant and it's true, we all originated from somewhere. The only people who are "true Americas" are the Native Americans. (pun intended). The Europeans and Spanish came to North America by boat. So, historically speaking, we were at one point as different as the North and South pole. To be able to come together for the thirteen colonies was like the first step of making a quilt. If I am correct, the original flag was a quilt as well which further symbolizes how the United States is "United" because everyone is bound together. If we speak in terms of the American culture, I definitely see how some people may think that the melting pot is bogus. To come together does not always mean you have to become homogeneous. Just like something as simple as PB&J sandwich. Who knew crushed up nuts and preserved fruit on bread would be a classic and taste so good? They go very well together and are often seen as the classic combination, but it doesn't mean they have to be all mixed and blended in a blender. Every single person in the United States is special. Whether it's their ancestor or their culture we all come together under the flag of the United States. And just like PB&J sandwich, we are unified and together, but it does not mean we have to be blended together. What makes us different makes as unique!
While reading your blog, I realized that often you find a way to include both perspectives on an idea. For example, you use the terms "some people" and "depends on the point of view". I agree with your thoughts in this post especially since you showed that you were open minded and recognized the other parties' perspective. Also, I found your PB&J sandwich metaphor cute. We're all different - jam, peanut butter and bread, and yet we unify together to create a delicious country! I also chuckled softly to myself when I read your Native American joke. It took me a good three seconds while to understand why you said (pun intended), but after I realized, I got a good giggle!
ReplyDeleteRawr hahaha I'm so sorry about the typo! I should fix that... I usually speed through my blog posts because I do "word vomit" and I just type away.
ReplyDelete